The World Pipe Band Championships is the ideal venue to hear pipe bands at their best. Bands build their performances throughout the year to peak at just the right time in August so that all things fall into place for Glasgow Green. So, how do the judges pick winners?
So many bands, so many great performances. It’s quite a challenge for the piping judge on the field. Having finely honed listening skills are certainly vital for the piping adjudicator, but learning and developing those listening skills are also as vital to us individual players as playing a good D throw.
What follows is a listening exercise to flex your piping knowledge-muscles. The three bands that follow form the top three winners in piping scores from the Grade 2 final at this year's Worlds. Good performances all, but have a listen and see if you can detect what piping elements would have caused the two piping judges to separate them the way they did. This in no way questions the judging that took place. There are no "right" answers either. The exercise tests the limits of your own piping knowledge as well as identifies areas where perhaps a bit more learning is needed. But looking back, we can listen critically and use these performances to play armchair judge and hone our own listening skills in the process.
Johnstone (piping placings: 1 & 1)
Police Service Northern Ireland (piping placings: 2 & 4)
Buchan Peterson (piping placings: 3 & 3)